[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Author Index][Search Archives]
MR-Disc: Song copyright
> > 3. I sing ["MS&C"] at a bardic circle, to a larger audience.
> Effectively a private party, no money involved, cool.
> I disagree: because you have not invited the audience, it isn't in your
> home, and it is something of a public performance, it is a violation of
> the copyright: even if it is not one that could generate a legal response.
If it can't generate a legal response, that leaves moral and ethical
grounds as possible reasons to avoid singing "MS&C" at a bardic circle.
Might it harm AEd the Bard, and/or make him tend to give up composing?
("I was going to buy that Errantry tape, but now that I heard Effen
sing that song from it, I don't have to.") I don't see it.
On a separate but related note, what are the copyright obligations
regarding filk songs? Would I owe Don MacLean anything if any of
the following hypothetical situations came to pass?
1. I sing, in the privacy of my own home, a song set to the tune
of "American Pie", but with words that are substantially different.
2. I sing it to myself while washing dishes at an event. Some people
may or may not overhear.
3. I sing it at a bardic circle that only allows invited guest within
4. I sing it at a bardic circle that's open to all.
5. I post the words on the Rialto, but don't mention anything about a tune.
6. I post the words on the Rialto, and say "to the tune of 'American Pie'"
7. I post some other words on the Rialto, and say "to the tune of
'American Pie'" although they are actually to a totally different
tune of my own invention, and don't fit "American Pie" at all.
Alfredo el Bufon
Elvegast, Windmaster's Hill, Atlantia
It's not who you know that counts, it's whom.
List Archives, FAQ, FTP: http://sca.wayfarer.org/merryrose/
Admin. requests: firstname.lastname@example.org